• About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact
Thursday, March 23, 2023
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
Papua Merdeka News
  • Home
    • Home – Layout 1
    • Home – Layout 2
    • Home – Layout 3
    • Home – Layout 4
    • Home – Layout 5
  • Roundups
  • Post Gerilya
  • Otsus Gagal
  • NKRI Bangkrut
  • Papua Merdeka
    • All
    • Demo & Aksi
    • Papua Post
    • Politik & Diplomasi
    • Post Gerilya
    • Sejarah
    Berduka Sedalam-Dalamnya Atas Meninggalnya Perwira Tinggi West Papua Army: Commander Gerardus Thommey

    Pertama kali saya bertemu bapak Gerardus Thommey di Belanda, dan mendengar semua cerita perjuangan dan perjalanan hidupnya

    Trump Is Struggling To Stay Calm On Russia, One Morning Call At A Time

    Republican Senator Vital to Health Bill’s Passage Won’t Support It

    Barack Obama and Family Visit Balinese Paddy Fields During Vacation

    Melania Trump’s Mail Suit Suggests Desire To Monetise First Lady Role

    This Secret Room In Mount Rushmore Is Having A Moment

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Media Post
    • All
    • Audio
    • Editorial & Column
    • Editorial & Columns
    • Gambar
    • Interviews
    • Opini & Analisis
    • Pesan Khusus
    • Post Press
    • Publikasi
    • Video
    • Wawancara
    Berduka Sedalam-Dalamnya Atas Meninggalnya Perwira Tinggi West Papua Army: Commander Gerardus Thommey

    Berduka Sedalam-Dalamnya Atas Meninggalnya Perwira Tinggi West Papua Army: Commander Gerardus Thommey

    Rev. Edison Waromi, S.H Resmi Pimpin Perdana Menteri (PM) dan Mr. Buchtar Tabuni memimpin Ketua West Papua Council Pemerintahan Sementara West Papua (ULMWP)

    Menteri Sekretaris Parlemen West Papua: ULMWP Akan Gelar Kongres, Bukan KTT

    Rap group call out publication for using their image in place of ‘gang’

    Melania Trump’s Mail Suit Suggests Desire To Monetise First Lady Role

    Bill Gates’ iconic donkey game arrives on iPhone, Apple Watch

    Johnny Depp Jokes About Assassinating Trump, Then Apologizes

    Uber’s Turbulent Week: Kalanick Out, New Twist In Google Lawsuit

    Uncharted: The Lost Legacy’s Latest Demo Shows A Treasure-Hunting Duo In Sync

    Hannah Donker talks being The Weeknd’s love interest in ‘Secrets’

  • Post Topics
    • All
    • Alam Bicara
    • Human Rights
    • Masyarakat Adat
    • Neo-colonialism
    • Perempuan Papua
    • Terorisme
    • Terrorism

    Republican Senator Vital to Health Bill’s Passage Won’t Support It

    Rap group call out publication for using their image in place of ‘gang’

    Barack Obama and Family Visit Balinese Paddy Fields During Vacation

    Melania Trump’s Mail Suit Suggests Desire To Monetise First Lady Role

    This Secret Room In Mount Rushmore Is Having A Moment

    A Digital Media Startup Growing Up With Millennial Women

    India Is Bringing Free Wi-fi To More Than 1,000 Villages This Year

    Indonesia’s Largest Fleet Of Taxis Teams Up To Beat Ride-hailing Apps

    Johnny Depp Jokes About Assassinating Trump, Then Apologizes

    Uber’s Turbulent Week: Kalanick Out, New Twist In Google Lawsuit

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Home
    • Home – Layout 1
    • Home – Layout 2
    • Home – Layout 3
    • Home – Layout 4
    • Home – Layout 5
  • Roundups
  • Post Gerilya
  • Otsus Gagal
  • NKRI Bangkrut
  • Papua Merdeka
    • All
    • Demo & Aksi
    • Papua Post
    • Politik & Diplomasi
    • Post Gerilya
    • Sejarah
    Berduka Sedalam-Dalamnya Atas Meninggalnya Perwira Tinggi West Papua Army: Commander Gerardus Thommey

    Pertama kali saya bertemu bapak Gerardus Thommey di Belanda, dan mendengar semua cerita perjuangan dan perjalanan hidupnya

    Trump Is Struggling To Stay Calm On Russia, One Morning Call At A Time

    Republican Senator Vital to Health Bill’s Passage Won’t Support It

    Barack Obama and Family Visit Balinese Paddy Fields During Vacation

    Melania Trump’s Mail Suit Suggests Desire To Monetise First Lady Role

    This Secret Room In Mount Rushmore Is Having A Moment

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Media Post
    • All
    • Audio
    • Editorial & Column
    • Editorial & Columns
    • Gambar
    • Interviews
    • Opini & Analisis
    • Pesan Khusus
    • Post Press
    • Publikasi
    • Video
    • Wawancara
    Berduka Sedalam-Dalamnya Atas Meninggalnya Perwira Tinggi West Papua Army: Commander Gerardus Thommey

    Berduka Sedalam-Dalamnya Atas Meninggalnya Perwira Tinggi West Papua Army: Commander Gerardus Thommey

    Rev. Edison Waromi, S.H Resmi Pimpin Perdana Menteri (PM) dan Mr. Buchtar Tabuni memimpin Ketua West Papua Council Pemerintahan Sementara West Papua (ULMWP)

    Menteri Sekretaris Parlemen West Papua: ULMWP Akan Gelar Kongres, Bukan KTT

    Rap group call out publication for using their image in place of ‘gang’

    Melania Trump’s Mail Suit Suggests Desire To Monetise First Lady Role

    Bill Gates’ iconic donkey game arrives on iPhone, Apple Watch

    Johnny Depp Jokes About Assassinating Trump, Then Apologizes

    Uber’s Turbulent Week: Kalanick Out, New Twist In Google Lawsuit

    Uncharted: The Lost Legacy’s Latest Demo Shows A Treasure-Hunting Duo In Sync

    Hannah Donker talks being The Weeknd’s love interest in ‘Secrets’

  • Post Topics
    • All
    • Alam Bicara
    • Human Rights
    • Masyarakat Adat
    • Neo-colonialism
    • Perempuan Papua
    • Terorisme
    • Terrorism

    Republican Senator Vital to Health Bill’s Passage Won’t Support It

    Rap group call out publication for using their image in place of ‘gang’

    Barack Obama and Family Visit Balinese Paddy Fields During Vacation

    Melania Trump’s Mail Suit Suggests Desire To Monetise First Lady Role

    This Secret Room In Mount Rushmore Is Having A Moment

    A Digital Media Startup Growing Up With Millennial Women

    India Is Bringing Free Wi-fi To More Than 1,000 Villages This Year

    Indonesia’s Largest Fleet Of Taxis Teams Up To Beat Ride-hailing Apps

    Johnny Depp Jokes About Assassinating Trump, Then Apologizes

    Uber’s Turbulent Week: Kalanick Out, New Twist In Google Lawsuit

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
No Result
View All Result
Papua Merdeka News
No Result
View All Result
Home Media Post Editorial & Columns

Can the US Marines Help Build Indonesia’s Amphibious Capabilities?

by admin
September 10, 2015
in Editorial & Columns
0
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterEmail

The Diplomat.cm – By Grant Newsham and Swee Lean Collin Koh, September 10, 2015

s a vast archipelagic nation-state prone to natural disasters, having a strong amphibious capability would appear to be a natural requirement for Indonesia. And as a part of the Indonesian Navy, the Marine Corps (Korps Marinir or KORMAR) has a key role to play in humanitarian assistance and disaster relief (HA/DR). Under the Minimum Essential Force (MEF) blueprint, Indonesia envisages by 2024 a greenwater navy capable of undertaking missions within its immediate regional waters as well as limited outreach beyond.

Under former President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, KORMAR, much like its sister branches, did experience some qualitative improvements. There was expected to continue under current President Joko Widodo, who in November 2014 outlined a vision of Indonesia as a Global Maritime Fulcrum. Of the five pillars of this vision, enhancing maritime defense lends further impetus for the ongoing MEF plan. Moreover, this pillar implicitly goes beyond continuing the primary focus of equipment upgrades. In particular, there is more to amphibious capacity-building than simply acquiring the hardware.

For instance, even an advanced, relatively well-funded navy such as the Japan Maritime Self Defense Force (JMSDF) faces similar challenges. In the aftermath of the Tohoku earthquake and tsunami in 2011, the JMSDF arrived on scene within a matter of hours. However, since it had no real amphibious capability – despite having some amphibious hardware – there was practically nothing to be done except to sit offshore while an estimated 3,000 to 4,000 survivors – who otherwise could have been saved – froze to death in the first 24-48 hours. Hence, there are some very practical reasons for developing and improving amphibious capabilities.

Opportunity for Engagement

Building amphibious capabilities certainly includes intensifying training, including engagement with foreign counterparts. Being traditionally more accustomed to bilateral, intra-Southeast Asian joint training and exercises, it is apparent that KORMAR seeks to develop a new area of expertise in broader region-wide initiatives. Notably, it played a key role in Indonesia-hosted Exercise Komodo, a multinational HA/DR exercise held in early 2014. And during the most recent Rim of the Pacific exercise hosted by the U.S., KORMAR deployed a contingent that performed admirably.

However, the Indonesians have room for improvement. An ambitious slew of initiatives is in the works: upgrading of aging hardware, improving personnel welfare, and developing human capital. The last aspect ties in with former Indonesian Navy chief Admiral Marsetio’s idea of a “World Class Navy” – increasing the quality of Indonesian naval servicemen (KORMAR personnel included), which can be accomplished through enhanced professional military education and training. This includes expanded interactions with foreign counterparts to learn and share best practices. It is thus clear that capacity-building for KORMAR is going to be more than acquiring new amphibious fighting vehicles or landing vessels. Although Jakarta might fulfill these requirements on its own, it can benefit from external assistance in its capacity-building efforts.

Washington has an opportunity to step up to this. In the revised version of “A Cooperative Strategy for 21st Century Seapower” published in March this year, an increase in U.S. strategic attention to the Indo-Asia-Pacific region is envisaged. The U.S. Marine Corps (USMC) is designated to maintain a Marine Expeditionary Force and Marine Expeditionary Unit in the region, and deploy a Marine Rotational Force to Australia as well as introducing new assets, such as the MV-22 Osprey. One of the objectives spelt out in this revised U.S. document is to enhance regional partnerships through expanded maritime security operations, shared maritime domain awareness and longer multilateral engagements. The aim is to build and sustain regional capacities to deal with local maritime security challenges.

Seen in this light, the USMC has a major role to play in helping to build the amphibious capacities of regional militaries, not least the Indonesians. The only question is how. To date, Washington has maintained a set of military engagements with Jakarta since the lifting of the arms embargo. This includes the extension of technical aid, such as helping Indonesia build an integrated maritime surveillance system network for maritime security purposes, as well as continuing the customary joint training and exercises, such as the Cooperation Afloat Readiness and Training (CARAT) series.

Expanding the Scope

Just recently, the U.S. and Indonesia completed this year’s iteration of the CARAT exercise. This is useful, but what matters more is what happens the 360 days of the year when the Americans are not around to help sustain Indonesia’s amphibious capacity-building efforts. The U.S. Department of Defense’s current approach of conducting short-duration joint training and exercises with the Indonesians a few times annually is so short-term that it tends to shortchange amphibious development. This is hardly in line with the stated goals of the revised maritime strategy for the Indo-Asia-Pacific region, not least if one considers Indonesia a key U.S. partner seen in the light of its geostrategic position.

Perhaps the key to drawing out the Indonesians is having Marines permanently assigned to KORMAR, as a means of building a more durable relationship via daily interactions. This approach has proven effective in Australia, Japan and South Korea. Stationing the right USMC personnel in Indonesia could help Jakarta play a larger role in Indo-Asia-Pacific and also assist in its Global Maritime Fulcrum vision. However, any such move would have to be calibrated, taking into consideration several potential hurdles in the way.

For example, Jakarta may be concerned about creating the wrong perceptions by allowing this permanent USMC presence. Domestically, it may also constitute a time-bomb with some constituents likely perceiving it as a move by Washington to further intensify its military footprint in the region. Even moderates will be worried whether it might trigger a potential regional backlash, not least having Indonesia seen by Beijing as being complicit in a U.S.-led containment effort.

One way to circumvent these obstacles is to proceed gradually. For a start, one USMC officer serving as advisor can based in Indonesia with KORMAR, or if necessary in the U.S. Embassy in Jakarta. The idea is to furnish a platform from which the officer can constantly interact with KORMAR, and promote and assist Indonesia’s amphibious capability building. The candidate would have to be carefully selected. He or she would need to have appreciable knowledge of Indonesia and its culture. This officer also needs to be able to operate in think-tank, media, and defense policy circles in order to sell “amphibiosity.” Fortuitously, the USMC has a number of potential candidates.

If this pilot scheme is successful, the logical next step would be to station a small USMC advisory team. This phase can possibly be accomplished without local political opposition so long as the USMC officer works the ground correctly and assiduously. In sum, enhancing USMC engagement with KORMAR would have to start small and aim for gradual progress appropriate for Indonesia’s amphibious capacity-building.

Some Final Thoughts

Unless the idea of amphibious operations is continuously pushed, it tends to fade into the background and be seen as a distraction from more “important” military operations. There seems to be a sort of equilibrium in most militaries, by which the individual armed services naturally focus on the core functions and capacities they consider most important, foremost being warfighting capabilities such as fighter jets, tanks, and combat ships and submarines. Moreover, the individual services do not naturally cooperate with each other. Yet amphibious capabilities require “some of each,” as the services must cooperate for joint operations combining sea/ground/air capabilities. This can be deemed contrary to the natural order of things in any military.

Not surprisingly, then, amphibious capabilities tend to be overlooked and when the need arises the services scramble to respond – and usually not very well. Once the need “recedes,” things go back to the equilibrium. This certainly applies to the case of Indonesia. Following the Indian Ocean earthquake and tsunami in December 2004, Jakarta endeavored to bolster HA/DR capabilities. The purchase of new landing platform, dock vessels was one major initiative. But over the past decade, it is also evident that the equilibrium has taken hold as Indonesia began to pay less attention to amphibious capabilities.

Inserting a USMC officer into Indonesia would be intended to keep this equilibrium from asserting itself, at least initially. The USMC has substantial expertise and knowledge to share with its Indonesian counterpart. And such new initiatives would be in line with the stated objectives of the revised maritime strategy. In consequence, a “building block” approach by doing it the correct way, with minimum political fuss, will facilitate not just KORMAR’s amphibious capacity-building but also enhance the U.S. military partnership with Indonesia. This will help more fully manifest Washington’s commitment to its Asia “rebalancing” efforts.

Grant Newsham is senior research fellow at the Japan Forum for Strategic Studies, based in Tokyo, and a retired U.S. Marine Colonel. He served as the first U.S. Marine Liaison Officer to the Japan Ground Self Defense Force from 2011-2013 and was instrumental in the development of the Japan Self Defense Force’s nascent amphibious capability. He remains active in amphibious development in the Indo-Asia-Pacific region. Swee Lean Collin Koh is associate research fellow at the Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies, a constituent unit of the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, based in Nanyang Technological University, Singapore. He primarily researches on naval modernization in Southeast Asia.

Tags: USA Support
admin

admin

Next Post

Tanda Heran di Honiara Menjadi Tonggak Sejarah Baru bagi Melanesia

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recommended

Sekretaris Jenderal PBB kedua, Dag Hammarskjold

Sekjen PIF berjanji isu West Papua akan didengarkan oleh pemimpin PIF

6 years ago

10 Tahun ” Biak Berdarah” Diperiganti

15 years ago

Popular News

    Connect with us

    Category

    Archives

    Tags

    Amunggut Tabi (78) Australia (38) Benny Wenda (67) demonstrasi (91) dialogue (58) dukungan internasional (88) dukungan MSG (43) dukungan regional (75) dukungan Solomon Islands (41) dukungan Vanuatu (47) features (232) gelagat Papua "M" (99) gelagat penjajah (219) gerilya kampung (55) gerilya kota (92) gerilya rimba (118) HAM (82) hukum kolonial (124) hut (71) kasus HAM (61) kasus penembakan (57) KNPB (77) Manasseh Sogavare (51) Mathias Wenda (59) MSG (70) MSG Membership (40) opini Papindo (58) Opini Papua (69) opini penjajah (50) OPM (53) Otsus gagal (115) Otsus Plus (56) pelanggaran HAM (46) penembakan (58) pesan trwp (49) politik Papua Merdeka (47) politik penjajah (73) referendum (54) teror polri (84) teror tni (82) tokoh Papua Merdeka (50) TPN OPM (58) TRWP (47) ULMWP (295) West Papua (114)

    Site Links

    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.org

    About Us

    We bring you the best Premium WordPress Themes that perfect for news, magazine, personal blog, etc. Check our landing page for details.

    • About
    • Advertise
    • Careers
    • Contact

    © 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • Post Gerilya
    • Roundups
    • Otsus Gagal
    • NKRI Bangkrut
    • Senasib
    • Media Post
    • Gambar
    • Video
    • Audio
    • Interviews
    • Terrorism
    • Post Topics
    • Perempuan Papua
    • Papua Merdeka
    • Alam Bicara
    • Food

    © 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

    Welcome Back!

    Sign In with Facebook
    Sign In with Google
    OR

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password?

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In

    Add New Playlist

    Are you sure want to unlock this post?
    Unlock left : 0
    Are you sure want to cancel subscription?
    Go to mobile version